Frigidaire Freezer Not Freezing: Causes and Solutions

A Frigidaire freezer that isn't maintaining temperature puts your food at risk and can cost you hundreds of dollars in spoiled groceries. Whether you own a Frigidaire FFFU16F2VV upright freezer, a FFFC09M1RW chest freezer, a Frigidaire Gallery FGVU21F8QF, or a Frigidaire Professional FPFU19F8RF, the causes of freezing failure follow a predictable pattern. This guide covers all seven common causes with specific diagnostic steps and repair information.

Understanding Freezer Temperature Standards

The FDA recommends maintaining your freezer at 0°F (-18°C) for safe food storage. Most Frigidaire freezers are designed to operate between -10°F and 10°F depending on the temperature setting. If your freezer is above 10°F, food safety is compromised. Above 32°F, frozen food begins to thaw.

Important: Use a standalone freezer thermometer (about $5–$10) rather than relying on the built-in temperature display. Place it in the center of the freezer, away from walls and vents, for the most accurate reading.

1. Dirty Condenser Coils

Just like refrigerators, freezers rely on condenser coils to release heat from the refrigeration system. When these coils are covered in dust, the compressor works harder and may not maintain target temperatures.

Location on Frigidaire freezers:

• Upright models: Usually at the back of the unit (external access) or at the bottom behind a kick plate.
• Chest freezers: Typically built into the outer walls — these are generally maintenance-free as wall-mounted condensers don't accumulate dust the same way.

How to clean (upright models):

1. Unplug the freezer.
2. Pull it away from the wall.
3. Use a condenser coil brush (narrow, long bristle brush) to clean between the coil fins.
4. Vacuum the loosened dust and debris.
5. Push the freezer back and restore power.

Maintenance: Clean condenser coils every 6–12 months. This alone can improve cooling efficiency by 15–20%.

2. Evaporator Fan Motor Failure

The evaporator fan circulates cold air throughout the freezer compartment. Without it, the evaporator coils chill only the area immediately around them, leaving the rest of the freezer warm.

Symptoms:

• Parts of the freezer are cold (near the coils) but other areas are warm
• No air movement from the vents inside the freezer
• Unusual buzzing, clicking, or grinding from behind the rear interior panel
• Heavy frost on the evaporator coils but warm air in the main compartment

How to diagnose:

1. Open the freezer door. On most Frigidaire models, the fan stops when the door opens.
2. Find and press the door switch (small plunger on the door frame) to simulate a closed door.
3. Listen for the fan. If it doesn't run, the motor has likely failed.
4. Access the fan by removing the rear interior panel (4–8 screws). Check if the fan blade is frozen to the motor shaft. If so, defrost it and see if the motor runs. If the blade is free but the motor doesn't run, the motor is dead.

Frigidaire evaporator fan motor part numbers:

• 242077702 — Most Frigidaire upright freezers
• 240369701 — Some Gallery and Professional models
• 297250000 — Some chest freezer models (less common to fail)

Cost: $25–$60 for the motor. Professional repair runs $150–$250.

3. Defrost System Malfunction

Frost-free Frigidaire freezers use an automatic defrost system to periodically melt frost from the evaporator coils. If the defrost system fails, frost builds up until it blocks airflow completely.

Symptoms:

• Gradual temperature increase over 1–3 weeks
• Heavy frost or ice visible behind the rear interior panel
• The freezer recovers after manual defrosting but the problem returns

Defrost components to check:

1. Defrost heater (241854301 or 5303918341): A resistance heater mounted near the evaporator coils. Test for continuity — should read 20–60 ohms. Open circuit = burned out.

2. Defrost thermostat (241852802 or 5303918202): A temperature-sensitive switch that closes to allow current to the heater when the evaporator temperature drops below approximately 15°F. Test for continuity when cold — should be closed (continuity). If open when cold, it's failed.

3. Defrost timer (215846602) or Defrost control board (241508001): The timer/board initiates defrost cycles at regular intervals (every 6–12 hours depending on the model). If the timer contacts fail or the board malfunctions, defrost never initiates.

Quick defrost system test:

1. Unplug the freezer for 24 hours with the door open.
2. Plug it back in. If temperatures return to normal and then gradually rise over the next 1–2 weeks, the defrost system is the culprit.

4. Faulty Temperature Control Thermostat

The temperature control thermostat (also called the cold control) determines when the compressor and fan motors run. If it fails in the open position, the compressor won't start.

How to test:

1. Turn the thermostat dial from the lowest to highest setting. You should hear a distinct click as it engages.
2. If no click, unplug the freezer and test the thermostat for continuity at the coldest setting. It should show continuity (circuit closed).

Part number: 216715200 (fits many Frigidaire freezer models). Cost: $25–$50.

5. Start Relay Failure

The start relay (also called the compressor relay or PTC relay) assists the compressor motor during startup. If it fails, the compressor can't start.

Symptoms:

• Clicking sound every 2–5 minutes (compressor tries to start, fails, overload protector trips, cycle repeats)
• Complete silence from the compressor (it never attempts to start)
• The freezer interior is at room temperature

How to test:

1. Unplug the freezer.
2. Access the compressor (rear of the unit, at the bottom).
3. Remove the start relay — it's a small device plugged into the compressor's terminal pins.
4. Shake the relay. A rattling sound indicates a broken contact inside.
5. Test continuity between the start and run terminals — should show 3–12 ohms.

Part number: 216594300 or 241707701. Cost: $10–$30.

6. Compressor Failure

The compressor is the most expensive component in the freezer. When it fails, there's no cooling at all.

Symptoms:

• No cooling whatsoever
• Compressor doesn't run (and start relay is good)
• Compressor hums briefly then cuts out (overload protector tripping due to a locked rotor)
• Compressor runs but doesn't pump refrigerant (mechanical failure — the unit runs quietly but doesn't cool)

How to test:

1. With the start relay removed, test the compressor windings. Measure resistance between the three compressor pins:
   • Common to Start: 8–20 ohms
   • Common to Run: 3–10 ohms
   • Start to Run: Sum of the above
2. Also check for ground fault — test continuity between each pin and the compressor body. Any continuity = ground fault (compressor must be replaced).

Cost: Compressor replacement runs $400–$800 including refrigerant recharge and labor. For freezers over 8 years old, replacement of the entire unit is usually more economical.

Warranty: Frigidaire typically provides a 5-year limited warranty on sealed system components (compressor, evaporator, condenser). Check your warranty before paying for compressor service.

7. Door Seal Problems

A damaged or worn door gasket allows warm, humid air to constantly enter the freezer, causing excessive frost buildup and overworking the cooling system.

Symptoms:

• Visible frost buildup on the door frame or gasket area
• Condensation or ice on the inner walls
• The compressor runs almost continuously
• Higher-than-normal electricity bills

The dollar bill test:

1. Close the door on a dollar bill so it's half in, half out.
2. Try to pull the bill out. A good seal provides noticeable resistance — the bill should drag, not slide freely.
3. Test at multiple points around the door perimeter.

How to fix:

1. Clean the gasket: Wipe the gasket with warm, soapy water to remove food residue and mold that may prevent a seal.
2. Reshape the gasket: If the gasket has deformed, use a hair dryer on low heat to warm and soften it, then close the door and let it cool into shape.
3. Apply petroleum jelly: A thin layer on the gasket surface can temporarily improve a marginal seal.
4. Replace the gasket: If it's torn, cracked, or permanently deformed, order a replacement specific to your model (Frigidaire gaskets use 241872502, 241786005, or model-specific numbers). Cost: $40–$120 depending on the model and door size.

Frigidaire Freezer Temperature Not Stable — Other Factors

Some issues aren't component failures but usage-related:

• Overloading: A packed freezer restricts airflow. Leave 2–3 inches of space around the walls and vents for air circulation.
• Warm food: Placing large amounts of warm/hot food directly into the freezer raises the internal temperature significantly. Cool food to room temperature before freezing.
• Ambient temperature: If the freezer is in a garage or unheated space, extreme ambient temperatures (below 40°F or above 110°F) can affect performance. Most Frigidaire freezers are designed for 55°F–110°F ambient.
• Door openings: Frequent or prolonged door openings introduce warm, humid air. Minimize door open time.
• Power fluctuations: Brownouts or voltage sags can prevent the compressor from running at full capacity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why is my Frigidaire freezer running but not freezing? A: If the compressor is running (you hear a steady hum) but the freezer isn't cold, the most likely causes are dirty condenser coils, a failed evaporator fan, or frost buildup on the evaporator from a defrost system failure. Start by cleaning the condenser coils (if accessible) and listening for the evaporator fan when the door is closed.

Q: What temperature should my Frigidaire freezer be set to? A: The FDA recommends 0°F (-18°C) for safe food storage. On Frigidaire freezers with a 1–9 dial, setting 5 usually corresponds to approximately 0°F. Use a standalone thermometer to verify, as dial settings aren't precisely calibrated.

Q: How long does a Frigidaire freezer last? A: Frigidaire chest freezers typically last 15–20 years with minimal maintenance. Upright freezers last 12–17 years. The compressor usually outlasts all other components. Regular condenser coil cleaning (on upright models) and door gasket maintenance are the keys to longevity.

Q: Can I put my Frigidaire freezer in the garage? A: Yes, but with limitations. Standard Frigidaire freezers are designed for 55°F–110°F ambient temperatures. In a garage that drops below 40°F in winter, the compressor may not run often enough, and the freezer may actually warm above the target temperature. Frigidaire sells "garage-ready" models (like the FFFU16F2VV) designed for wider temperature ranges.

Q: My Frigidaire freezer has thick ice on the walls. Is this normal? A: A thin layer of frost on the walls can be normal, especially in humid conditions. Thick ice buildup (more than 1/4 inch) is not normal and indicates either a defrost system failure (on frost-free models), a door seal problem, or excessive humidity infiltration. Manual-defrost models require periodic defrosting when ice exceeds 1/4 inch.

When to Call a Professional

Some Frigidaire freezer repairs require professional expertise:

• Sealed system service — Compressor replacement, refrigerant leak repair, and system recharge require EPA Section 608 certification and specialized equipment.
• Persistent defrost problems — If replacing defrost components doesn't solve the issue, there may be a wiring problem or an intermittent control board failure that requires systematic diagnosis.
• Compressor that runs but doesn't cool — This can indicate a refrigerant leak or a mechanical compressor failure (valves not sealing), both of which require professional diagnosis.
• Electrical issues — If the freezer trips the circuit breaker or shows signs of electrical damage (burning smell, discolored outlet), call a professional electrician and appliance technician.
• Built-in or panel-ready models — These require careful handling during service to avoid damaging custom cabinet panels.

Frigidaire freezer not keeping your food frozen? EasyBear provides free diagnostic visits for all Frigidaire freezer models — upright, chest, and built-in. Our certified technicians arrive with the most common Frigidaire parts and can complete most repairs on the spot. Every repair is backed by our 90-day parts and labor warranty. Book your free diagnosis today and protect your frozen food investment.